Paradigm Files Comment Letter on the CFTC’s Event Contract Swap Rules
Today, Paradigm filed a comment letter with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission regarding two releases that, taken together, confirm that event contracts traded on regulated exchanges are swaps and that bets placed with state-licensed sportsbooks are not. That is a commonsense proposal, and we urge the Commission to finalize it.
In truth, however, it is surprising and unfortunate that the CFTC needed to put this in writing at all. The Commission has regulated event contracts as derivatives since exchanges first began listing them in 1992. Over the next three decades, exchanges have offered thousands of event contracts as swaps, the Commission has brought and settled enforcement actions on the theory that event contracts are swaps, and Congress even wrote a “special rule” for event contracts into the same law that defined “swap.” Every administration for more than thirty years has understood that bets and event contracts are different, even when they resolve on the same underlying occurrence. This proposal is a bit like the United States Geological Survey summoning its myriad experts together to officially proclaim that, yes, the Pacific Ocean is water.
But a growing chorus of gaming regulators and lobbyists no longer see the difference, so the Commission must provide the regulatory equivalent of that statement of hydrological fact. In doing so, the CFTC exposes the structural flaw at the heart of the fallacy that both of these products “walk like a duck”: by setting their own odds, taking the other side of every wager, and banning those who win, sportsbooks do not waddle, swim, or quack like a registered exchange that does none of those things. Of course, that’s not inherently a criticism of sportsbooks; it’s simply a recognition that they offer a different product serving a different purpose, which is why Congress gave them a different regulator.
And Congress did give event contracts a different regulator, as the Commodity Exchange Act confirms in multiple, independent places.
First, Congress defined “swap” to include any contract whose payment depends on an event “associated with a potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence.” Sports outcomes plainly qualify: as we detail in our letter, the Knicks’ 2026 title run generated $380 million for New York City, player contracts are routinely linked to individual performance bonuses, and star players drive TV and merchandise revenue.
Second, the definition separately covers any contract “commonly known to the trade as a swap.” It can hardly be denied that the trade has spoken clearly on this point: exchanges list and clear event contracts as swaps, the Futures Industry Association describes them as swaps, and the Commission treats them as swaps when it enforces the law.
And third, Congress authorized the CFTC to “further define” the term swaps, which is the same authority the Commission used in 2012 to exclude insurance and consumer transactions from the definition. It is using the same authority here, exactly as Congress intended.
Putting all of this in a regulation matters because markets need a stable foundation. The CFTC’s rules recognize that, and they do it the right way: using authority Congress gave it for exactly this purpose. We look forward to the final rule, and you can read Paradigm’s full comment letter here.